Step #3: Recruit From Your Networks

Top Grading

Hiring Step #3: Recruit From Your Networks, page 86.

  • Now that you have a clear, thorough Job Scorecard, it’s time to recruit candidates 
  • Everyone knows that it is best to recruit from your networks of high performers and others you know personally. 
  • Most leaders and managers say, “We just don’t get as many referrals from our people as we want.” 
  • A Players want to work with other A Players and are happy to refer A Players from their networks, but it just doesn’t happen often enough. Why? 
  • The answer is usually, “because everyone is too busy to stay in touch with their A Player former associates.” 
  • Topgraders have at least two types of Networks – A Players they have worked with and Connectors, people who know A Players they can refer. 
  • We recommend that every manager build and maintain lists of 20+ A Players and 10+ Connectors, people not suitable for your company, but who know a lot of high performers you might hire. 
  • The Connector group often includes:
    • Retirees who stay in touch with lots of talented people. 
    • Vendors with an eye for talent. 
    • Professional Associates. 
    • Former peers who know lots of As. 

Exercise: Create Your Network Lists 

  • List 20+ A Players you know and who might go to work for you. 
  • List 10+ Connectors who might refer A Players to you. 
  • List all professional associations and clubs that could be sources of candidates and Connectors. 

How Companies Boost Hiring Success Through Networks 

  • Topgrading companies understand how to get busy, sharp high performers to allocate time to stay in touch with A Players and Connectors. Their strategies include:
    • Make recruiting through Network a Job Scorecard Accountability.
    • Require your team to submit regular updates. 
    • Require managers to discuss their networks with their subordinates at least quarterly, to be sure subordinate networks are being properly maintained, and to report the results. 
    • Require managers to recommend at least one person per year who is hired and who turns out to be an A Player a year later. 
    • Pay bonuses (sometimes called “bounties”) for referrals. 
    • Encourage high performers to use social networks (Facebook, Linked In, etc.).
    • Ask new hires for their network lists. 
    • Make a point of encouraging networking, at least weekly. 
    • Don’t rely solely on email; use the telephone, Zoom, and any method to have live, personal communications. 
    • Attract A Players by having exciting web pages, careers sections, and job ads.
    • When visitors to your career section learn what Topgrading is all about, C Players will get the message and stay away, and high performers, wanting to join a company with other high performers, will be apt to apply. 

What to do when Networks Aren’t Producing – Executive Search Firms 

  • Get the Best Results with Executive Search Firms. 
  • Favor boutique firms with 10 or fewer professionals. 
  • Request a written list of clients they cannot penetrate. 
  • Check references of key search executives before signing a contract. 
  • Sign a fixed fee contract that removed the incentive for the search firm to find more expensive candidates. 
  • Require thorough Job Scorecard plus several dozen competencies. 
  • Require weekly updates. 
  • Insist that they conduct Topgrading Interviews of all finalists. 
  • For finalists, insist on written reports citing mistakes and failures, not just accomplishments. 
  • For finalists, require candidate reports disclose six real weaknesses. 
  • Require reference-check summaries that disclose negatives, not just positives. 
  • Sign a contract requiring the search firm to not steal your company’s employees for three years. 
  • Evaluate some resumes, Career History Forms, Topgrading Snapshots, and Telephone Interview Screening notes early on to be sure you’re on the “same page.” 
  • Make yourself available to meet with candidates and search firm employees.